David Topi Werahiko Borell – a tribute

On Saturday 9 May, fifty years and one day after his death, representatives of Tauranga Historical were invited to gather with members of the Borell whānau  to commemorate their koro and our rangatira’s contributions to his community.

Paparoa marae, 9 May 2026  (Image: Beth Bowden)

Family man, famed sportsman and scholar, Mr David Borell of Te Puna was a member of the Tauranga Historical Society in various roles in the 1960’s.  He was on the Executive Committee for a long time, starting in 1963 and serving as Vice President for 1965 (the job was taken over by T. R. Te Kani in1966).  But his activities extended far beyond those administrative functions, and well into the century’s – and his – 70s.

Te Puna Rugby Team, 1920.  Davy Borell is third from left in the middle row. (Image: Te Ao Marama, 08-073)

Davy, as he was usually known, famously turned down the chance to play for the All Blacks because his wife was due to have a baby.  The confidence that underlay such a decision may have come from his earlier experience as a scholarship boy:  he had won his secondary education at a big-city school, Sacred Heart College in Glen Innes, Auckland, where he learned Latin, history and geography.  He spoke te reo all his life and moved effortlessly between te ao Māori and te ao pākehā.  In his retirement, he put these talents at the service of the Tauranga Historical Society.

In the Society’s September 1964 Journal (Number 21) [1] he published a long-form article titled “Historic Te Puna”.  Being the scholar he was, it took two full pages of background description of waka voyages, social context, and whakapapa before he actually got on to Te Puna;  and in the midst of this introduction is a small personal gem:  his father saw the famous, now lost, family portrait sent by Queen Victoria in return for a gift of a sack of wheat flour milled at Rangiawahia.  Davy mentions:

My father actually saw this portrait of the Royal Family, which he said measured about three feet by about four feet.  In 1932 communication was made to the then Governor through the authorities, for a possible replacement of that portrait or something similar, but of course the request proved negative.  It was I who wrote out the request and covered almost two foolscap sheets of writing paper.

Davy then goes on to describe, in order, the pā of Te Puna – Oikimoke, Epeha, Hamaruru, Raropua, Oturu, the strange and beautiful story of Hawaiki, the island pa of Tukoro, Hūharua on today’s Plummers Point, and the inland pa of Hopuni, Tawhitinui, Pukewhanake, Paerangi.

We must note here, given the current exhibition of toki at the Western Bay Museum:

The pā at Hakarua [Hūharua]… was a repository of scores of stone axe-heads.  Miss Violet Plummer, while I was there building at her home, showed me two boxes of these stone axe-heads.  Some of them were well polished, others were of a rougher nature, and the best ones she told me were sent away to the Auckland museum, a box full of them… a taiaha was found in swampy ground lower down… Who knows, there may be a lot of other old artifacts within or immediately outside that pā.

 Davy wrote beautifully, and was a great storyteller.  He could evoke character and personality, drama, emotion, and humour.  He describes the workings of the mill on the Wairoa River, and how his father Werahiko and Hone Bidois built St Joseph’s church.  He himself learned his carpenter’s trade from Werahiko.  As late as 1967 he was still using these skills for the benefit of the Society, making “a large cabinet” for the Society archives, “placed temporarily in the Sladden Library room adjoining the City Council Library.”  A suggestion that the cabinet was included in the Museum collection (Journal Number 42, April 1971) remains unconfirmed.

He was just as much at home of the water of Tauranga Moana as the mainland, and organised two trips, both involving launch travel, to entertain and inform Society members.  Under his guidance, in 1965 they enjoyed boating out to Ōmokoroa and thence (by bus) to Whakamārama; and, in 1966, took another trip out to Motuhoa Island, which started with a pōwhiri:

After these formalities were over, the tractors with their passengers and others who preferred to walk moved off towards the western end of the Island to the home of Mr. and Mrs. C. G. Borell.  It was a lengthy trudge, for those on foot, but it helped to build up a thirst and an appetite…Mr Peter Bidois, who is a highly respected elder of the Pirirakau tribe, extended a worm welcome to the visitors in traditional Māori style.  He likened their coming to the arrival of the early Māori fleet of canoes, with the winds, from the four corners of the earth, making the same waves that had carried both the visitors and the Māori people on their journeys.

Luncheon was then set on tables on the lawn…

By far the best story of island life, however, appeared in the April 1967 Journal (Number 30). It is an account of horse racing on Matakana Island, meetings which took place on New Year’s Day of 1919, 1920 and 1921: [2]

A Committee of management was elected, Mr. Aramoana Amohau being chairman and Mr. Turoia Kuka, secretary.  The first programme  was made known by way of notebook and verbal contacts.  The news spread like wildfire, and nominations were soon received for the various races.  … one such race horse, named Oaklands, a fine upstanding brown gelding, by appearance, and that alone; anyone would have deemed defeat in a race impossible; but alas, it was not to be.  Some of the Island half-racehorses which ran against Oaklands beat him to a frazzle. 

For the descriptions of the “Island half-racehorses”, and their names, and those of their owners, and the weight of their jockeys, and the adjudication of the races themselves, and the hilarious double-booking of the Tauranga Municipal Band that eventually triggered official intervention, you really do have to read the full article.  When Davy died eight years later, the Journal editor reprinted it, along with his obituary (Number 57, September 1976).

At the end of his very first article for the Journal, Davy expressed the fear that

As we are being borne aloft on the wings of progress and speeding on into the vortex of a faster world, the very things we loved and cherished are being swept away…

Screenshot of a Matakana Island beach race in 2012.  (Image: Stan Walker, J M Media)

At the commemoration we all agreed that he would be pleased to know that horses still occasionally race at Matakana Island. [3]  

 [1] All sources for the Journal references in this essay are available on Pae Koroki.  For the Collection Summary page, go to https://paekoroki.tauranga.govt.nz/nodes/view/23915

 [2] For a vigorous overview on horse racing activities in Tauranga, see Leabourn, B. From the Government Paddock to Group 1 Glory, especially Chapter 3.  https://paekoroki.tauranga.govt.nz/nodes/view/50640

 [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXgUvLgNpps&t=24s , JM Media

 

Life on Motuopuhi (Rat Island)

Guest article by Max Avery

Many may have looked with envy on the possibility of a Robinson Crusoe-like existence on a deserted Pacific Ocean island. Closer to home, in the Tauranga Harbour, that lonely life became a reality for William and Ethel O’Halloran when, about 1930, they took up residence on tiny Motuopuhi (Rat) Island, just off the Turret Rd foreshore.

Because of its proximity to the mainland, the island may appear to be readily accessible - and so it is , at low tide. At high tide, however, a channel a little more than two metres deep proves an effective defensive moat for inhabitants, and a barrier to prospective visitors.

Standard 4, Tauranga District High School, 1940
(Noeline O'Halloran, fourth row, second from left)
Image courtesy of Tauranga City Libraries, Pae Korokī, Ref. 02-239

So, what sort of a life did the couple face for the next 30 years, and how did they cope with it? We have, luckily, a manuscript penned by their grand-daughter, Noelene Smillie, and lodged in Tauranga City Archives, She explains that her grandfather, a farmer and racehorse trainer, had suffered severe renal failure and been told that he must take life more quietly and importantly, avoid alcohol at all times. Motuopuhi seemed the perfect prescription. The island was private, without easy access, complete with rudimentary house and was available in return for a nominal rental and caretaking duties - the control of scrub growth, rodents and junior arsonists, and breeding pens of quail and pheasants for the local acclimatisation society.

What Motuopuhi did not have was electricity, telephone communication and a  fresh water supply. The hardy couple made do for 30 years with kerosene lamps, their battery-powered radio gave them a link to the outside world, (visitors had to yell “Coooo-eeee” from Turret Road to attract attention), their manuka-fired Dover stove supplied heat for cooking and hot water, and in times of drought, when their rainwater supply from the roof failed, they tediously transported containers of water from the mainland in a tar-covered craft known as the Black Boat.

Motuopihi (Rat Island), Bay of Plenty Times, 9 June 1961
4x5" cellulose triacetate negative (damaged)
Image courtesy of Tauranga City Libraries, Pae Korokī, Ref. gcb-152

Interestingly while Motuopuhi had no fresh water, Will O’Halloran told his family that he had no doubt that there was a mineral spring below the surface, detected with a home-made triple-pronged divining rod, which granddaughter Noelene also proved. (She later heard a rumour that the Hilton Hotel chain planned a mineral-spa hotel on the island.)

Motuopuhi was indeed lacking in what even then were common amenities, but when it came to living off the land the island was a paradise. Noelene wrote: “A colourful abundance of beautiful flowers and shrubs cradled the silver-grey weather-beaten dwelling. The gardens were bright whatever the season. Lillies, daisies, dozens of dahlia, hollyhocks, delphinium, carnations, love-in-the-mist, thrift, honesty, rose bushes, and spring bulbs. Beyond the flower beds loomed the orchard, a massive plum tree towering over the cottage, a fig tree, peaches, apples, nectarines, citrus fruits, grapes, gooseberries and luscious red wineberries. All of these, and vegetables, did well in the sheltered environment.”

The harbour provided the O’Hallorans with many a meal, Noelene remembered: “Most of the male visitors were drawn by the fishing. A couple of hours netting around the island provided enough flounder to make a large pile on a handy sandbank. They were then gutted and strung into a bundle of flax. Some were to be sold, many to be given away. Other fish too - kahawai, millet, kingfish, even snapper, occasionally a ‘whopper’ like the 18-pounder my teenage brother hooked on a settling. It was not long before Will accepted the efficiency of the outboard motor and got one for himself. This made his whitebait forays much easier. He could go under the Harini Bridge, across the estuary and up the Waimapu River in a quarter of the time. In the season the arrival of the Ford on our front lawn with a kerosene tin full of the minute fish was a common sight.”

Extract from Bay of Plenty Jockey Club programme, 1916
Image courtesy of Tauranga City Libraries, Pae Korokī, Ref. Ams 12/5/5

Her mention of the Ford requires an explanation. Will O’Halloran owned Model T Ford motorcars throughout his life on Motuopuhi Island. He kept them in a garage on Turret Road and used them to get himself and Ethel into Tauranga township after negotiating the channel in the Black Boat. Noelene remembered: “His precious Ford! Will’s pride and joy! His mighty steed that took them both to race meetings at Te Rapa, Paeroa and Rotorua, over the Kaimai and Mamaku Ranges, conquering muddy roads, ice, and sometimes snow with the help of clanking chains. There had been a succession of them, always a Ford. We, my brother and I were not permitted to call our grandfather’s cars Lizzies. His last, and loveliest model was a ’T' which went to a collector across the Tasman in the late fifties.”

Will and Ethel O’Halloran found the quiet life they had been looking for on Motuopuhi, and Will regained his health, exercising his expertise in growing vegetables, pruning fruit trees and fishing, while blackbirds, kingfishers, gulls, shags, pied stilts and even moreporks flew around. He had built a substantial letter-box on Turret Road, and it was from this point that visitors “Cooo-eeed:”, and if they were lucky, were transported across the channel in the Black Boat. However, much as they enjoyed family and friends visiting, it was the quiet life they really relished, and it was a sad day when, due to old age and increasing medical emergencies, a move in the late 1950s to a Tauranga Hospital Board cottage in 15th Avenue near Turret Road was necessary.

Motuopuhi was so near, yet so far, and as Noelene noted: “The noise of the close traffic, door-to-door salespeople, unexpected visitors knocking on the door and using electric appliances was all new, and they found it difficult to settle.”

Caption for Tauranga DHS photo: Back row from left: Neville Gilmore-Rogers; Bob McGilp; Brian Fisk; Cliff Anquetil; Oswald McQuillan; Ivan O'Brien; Robin Green; Dennis McShane; Owen Mackay; Ray Snowden Second row: Pat Lowe; Val White; Brian Hartley; Owen Moxham; Neville Berridge; Brian Wenz lick; Huia Sutherland; Keith Holloway; David Auld; Margaret Webb; Audrey Kerridge Third row: Doreen Pemperton; Marie Pope; Pat Ridder; Shirley Willoughby; Ruth-Alice Gresham; Elva Jarvis; Joan Brewer; Freda Watkins; Margaret Jefferson; June Johnson; Fay Hunter; Ramona Potter Fourth row: Margaret Gaulton; Noelene O'Halloran; Dorothy Snow; Marie Lucas...ski [sic]; Jean Taylor; Diana Jordan; Myra Kivell; Betty Parkinson; Margaret Evans Front row: Joan Clark; Len Thompson; Geoff Woods; Ross Manson; Jim Bongard; Frank Robinson; Balfour Jacobson; Ruth Bryan

Tuhi Harvey (1908-1990)

Tuhi David Harvey was a giant of a man, not necessarily in stature but in strength and achievement. He was named by and for a Maori Chief and after his father David Harvey an English immigrant carpenter.* According to his eldest daughter Pat, “He was a soft touch for any genuine cause or misfortune, he drove luxury cars and lived in the fast lane.”

The youngest of at least twelve children he, like all his brothers, trained in carpentry and later became a master builder. Married to Maisie, a very young redhead from Taumaranui, they spent a few years in Australia and came home on ten pound tickets with two small children in 1932. Excelling at swimming and rowing he had done a stint as a Bondi Lifesaver.

Tuhi aged 20 as a Bondi Beach Lifesaver in 1930. Harvey Family Image

Sport and shows of his immense strength were a major part of his leisure time: rugby, rowing, golf tennis, and hunting to hounds. He cycled from their home in First Avenue to Mount Maunganui, via the Matapihi rail bridge, to work as a builder during those depression years for 10 ‘bob’ a day ($1). At night he made rowing skiffs and Maisie did lead-lighting to supplement their income.  

In 1938, by the time their third daughter Gaye was aged one, they had moved to a double-storey home in 11th Ave (where the Plaza shopping centre is now located.)  Then in ’42 he joined Harry Smith, a Dunedin bricklayer, in buying Pemberton Bros joinery factory on the Devonport Rd / First Ave Corner. (Tuhi had joined the Hauraki Regiment and trained as a gunner, but men with 4 children did not have to serve overseas, and son David was ‘on the way’ when his call-up came.) By 1949 they had over 100 men on the payroll, one of the Bay’s largest employers.

Smith Harvey Construction Ltd. BOP Year book, 1958
Courtesy of Tauranga Library Heritage & Research

Smith Harvey Construction Ltd. produced prefabricated houses as well as joinery and retail timber supplies. In 1945 they began to source their own timber and mill it themselves, including purchase of all the necessary milling gear and some blocks of bush in Oropi and Pyes Pa. Apparently Tuhi was quite conservative in his milling operations only taking some of the available rimu and tawa from each block. The sawmill was on Anglican church land next to the Mission Cemetery (where the Trinity Wharf Hotel is now) and this business was known as Tuhi Timbers.

They were one of the first local businesses to both export and import timber to and from South America. They were also one of the first three logging operations to export radiata pine to Japan from the Tauranga Wharf on Dive Crescent. All the timber was donated for the Dive Crescent Rowing club building which was built with volunteer labour by the members.

Vessel loading New Zealand pine for export to Australia, Tauranga Wharf, c1956

Around 1950 due to very limited yard space, a large tract of land in Chapel Street was used for the processing and storage of the sawn timber. There it was planed, stacked and dried, and in 1953 a treatment plant was added. Tuhi had pioneered what was known as boron treatment of tawa, thereby making it a durable product, and they churned out mainly weatherboard, tongue and groove flooring and tool handles. His daughter Gaye remembers going with him late in the evenings to change the hoses over as two consignments could be put through the gas treatment chambers in 24 hours. The Devonport Road site housed the office, joinery factory and timber sales.

Treatment plant and yard at Chapel Street

Gaye also informed me that during the 1950s her father owned and ran, in addition to all his other operations, a mill near Barkes Corner named Craven Wood. This fitted in rather neatly with his other business of breeding and racing horses, which in the end became his abiding passion.

Tuhi (on right) and friend hunting. Harvey Family image

Unfortunately due to sheer size Smith Harvey was forced into receivership in 1960, and in 1962 Charlie and Alf Odlin bought them out. In 1986 it was sold to Winstones Ltd who in turn allowed it to go to Fletchers and the mills and yards ceased trading in 1988, due to the government stopping indigenous logging operations.

* Tuhi’s mother Elizabeth Susan Harvey owned several tracts of land including Moturiki Island, next to the main Mount beach, which she sold to ‘the railways’ for the rock to construct the East Coast line.

Sources: Personal interview with Gaye Craig — Tuhi’s daughter
               Notes written by her late older sister Pat
               Article by Ron Lipinski on Tauranga Sawmills in BOP Times 1st Nov, 2006
               Bay of Plenty Yearbooks published by Astra Publicity, Auckland c 1956,1958
               Harvey family images